Skip to main content

Vintage Legends Countdown #48: 1965 Topps Johnny Mize

**In this series, I am counting down my personal favorite cards in the 2010 Topps Vintage Legends insert series from #50 to #1.**

Now don't get me wrong here, but Johnny Mize shouldn't really be in the Vintage Legends set. Yes, he's a grade A Hall of Famer and he lost three seasons to his World War II service but his stats are comparable to Moises Alou, Todd Helton, Hank Greenberg, [editor's comment: per dayf's comment, Hank has been removed from my snide comment...when I wrote it I knew I was going to have problems but I went with it anyway...I hope someday that I can all earn your trust again...] and Dick Allen...not exactly the "legend" category.

2010 Topps Vintage Legends #2 Johnny Mize
**To see the other entries in this countdown, check out the links on the right under the heading "Vintage Legends Countdown."**

Comments

dayf said…
Mize is ranked 61st all time in Career Offensive WAR, tied with Tony Gwynn and sandwiched between Harmon Killebrew and Mike Piazza:
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/WAR_off_career.shtml

Mize is 54th all time in WAR for position players, in between Jim Thome and Derek Jeter:
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/WAR_bat_career.shtml

In Adjusted OPS+ Mize is ranked 16th all time, right above Tris Speaker and just below Stan Musial.
http://www.baseball-reference.com/leaders/onbase_plus_slugging_plus_career.shtml

He's tied in OPS+ with Hank Greenberg and - don't take this the wrong way - if you don't think Hank is a legend than you got some baseball learnin' to do. Hank is as legendy as you get.

Plus his nickname was Big Jawn. Don't you wish your nickname was Big Jawn?
Matt Flaten said…
This comment has been removed by the author.
Matt Flaten said…
A 1,000 pardons on the Greenberg comment and it's been corrected but your stats are sort of making my case. Mize is great, but not a legend. This set has so many undeniably better players it just seems like Mize and Pee Wee Reese are just sort of squeezed in there.

And why didn't they include Greenberg by the way?

Popular posts from this blog

Schrödinger's cat of trading cards or can you really have a mint Topps Finest card from the 90's?

They are the Schrödinger's cat of trading cards -- Topps cards from the 90's with the plastic protector still on them.  They are cards that are out the pack and yet you truly don't know their condition because there is that second sheet of plastic. When I can't get to sleep, sometimes my mind turns to the card collector's unanswerable existential question: Can there really be a mint Topps Finest card when the protective coating is on the card? Just like the cat in Schrodinger's box that is either alive or dead, the card can be mint or damaged by the plastic protector and there is no way to know without ripping that sucker off.   To me it is like grading a card still in the wrapper. You don't know the condition of the card until you open the pack, just like you can't really know the condition of the card until that annoying plastic coating is removed.  For years, I've been doing just that in a series of posts I've called "Free the Finest....

The 1st Heartbreaking Contest: Help Me Identify My Dumpster Cards

I've been trying to come up with some kind of original contest to do and on Friday everything came into place like a lightening bolt from the sky. In the morning I got the garbage together and walked over to the two garbage bins that service the entire town home complex that I live at. I tossed the bags in the trash and was turning around when something caught my eye...This is what I saw: THE HORROR! Someone had decided to get rid of their baseball card collection the worst way possible [besides trying to charge $2,500 for them on eBay ]...It was just starting to rain as well so I ran into the house, got myself a shovel, and was able to save three boxes of cards that had been covered by another box and missed the rain entirely: So had I stumbled upon a box of 1952 Mickey Mantles that some careless mother had just thrown out? Was there a T206 Honus just waiting for the auction block? Sadly no...two of the boxes had mixed singles in them and one had a complete set. Here's w...

Examining Marvel's Power Grid From 1993 Skybox Marvel Universe Packs

I think it is fair to say that at the point Skybox issued this Marvel Universe set in 1993 it was the most important card set of my young life. Way more important than any football or baseball set. It's probably the only set as a kid I was able to complete from buying wax packs and I was always on the hunt for the rarer insert cards. I recently found a whole bunch of random packs at a card show for 25 ¢ each.  One thing I appreciated now is that on the inside of the wrappers Skybox and Marvel give us a handy guide to understanding the powers score that each hero or villain receives on the back of each card. You've got categories like agility, durability, energy projection, mental powers, and speed each broken down score by score in their 1-7 scoring system. You don't get all the information on one pack and it's pretty hard to make out some of the scores so I've gone through all my wrappers and made a chart of each power and super hero or two tha...